Historian reveals most ridiculous understatements in British history

  • A historian at the University of Sheffield has named the 20 biggest understatements in British history
  • Impact, historical importance of the event and quality of the quote used to  develop the final list
  • “By God, sir, I’ve lost my leg!” “By God, sir, so you have!” is the best example of British understatement ever recorded, and is credited as having inspired Monty Python
     

A history research fellow has released a list of the 20 biggest understatements in British history. Commissioned by Privilege insurance, Dr Tom Dowling analysed historical records and events stretching back over the last 200 years. 

Once collated, the statements were ranked according to how well-known the statement is (impact), the importance of the event they relate to, and the quality of the statement itself (based on humour and intellect).

At number one, the best example of understatement in British history is the mild-mannered exchange between the Earl of Uxbridge and the Duke of Wellington, as the Earl’s leg was blown off by a canon during the Battle of Waterloo. The Earl reportedly remarked “By God, Sir, I’ve lost my leg!” to which the Duke of Wellington responded: “By God, Sir, so you have!”. The exchange was later credited as the inspiration for a scene in Monty Python’s The Meaning of Life, where an English Army officer fighting in the Zulu War nonchalantly considers the leg that has just been bitten off by a tiger.

The Earl’s words are followed by British Airways Pilot Eric Moody’s message to passengers over the tannoy when the engines failed flying through a volcanic ash cloud: “Ladies and Gentlemen, this is your captain speaking. We have a small problem. All four engines have stopped…”.

Captain Lawrence Oates’s declaration “I am just going outside and may be some time” comes in third place. Oates made the statement as he knowingly walked out of his tent to his death on an ill-fated expedition to the South Pole.

Also included in the tables is Sir Alexander Fleming’s modest comment on one of the most important medical discoveries of the 20th century; penicillin. Fleming commented: “One sometimes finds what one is not looking for” (sixth place).

The Queen’s response when asked how she was following ‘Brexit’ also makes the list, in 15th place. After some thought she remarked: “Well, I’m still alive anyway.”

Dowling carried out the research as part of a study on ‘Britishness’ by Privilege insurance. The aim was to find out how deeply understatement is written into Britain’s national character, with the hypothesis that the extent of its use is indicative of how British people have chosen to project themselves to each other and the wider world.

Dan Simson, head of Privilege home insurance, comments: “Britain is full of quirks and the peculiar quality of British understatement is something that we found interesting. We commissioned this research to give us further insight into what makes Britain, and our customers, tick.”

Dr Tom Dowling, Honorary Research Fellow and Associate Tutor in the Department of History at the University of Sheffield, explains: “Although understatement can be traced as far back as Saxon times in Britain with the epic Old English poem, Beowulf, it is the expansion of British imperial power in the nineteenth century, which truly cemented understatement as a central hallmark of British character. Emotionalism and over-exaggeration, it seems, were ill-suited to the demands of running an Empire.

“This list reveals how, over the last two centuries, Britons have employed understatement as both a way of confronting moments of crisis and of evading them. As author of ‘How to be a Brit’, George Mikes, once observed, understatement is more than just a speciality of the British sense of humour – “it is a way of life”.”
 

Biggest British Understatements of All Time: Top 20

Source: Privilege insurance

     

1. “By God, sir, I’ve lost my leg!”

“By God, sir, so you have!”

 

Henry William Paget, Earl of Uxbridge.

 

Reportedly in exchange with the Duke of Wellington.

 

In the last moments of the Battle of Waterloo on June 18, 1815, Paget’s right leg was struck by a cannon, necessitating its amputation.

 

The leg itself was later put on display as a tourist attraction, near the site of the battle in Waterloo.

 

Paget’s pluck almost certainly provided inspiration for the scene in Monty Python’s The Meaning of Life in which an English Army officer fighting in the Zulu War nonchalantly considers the leg that has just been bitten off by a tiger.

2. “Ladies and Gentlemen, this is your captain speaking. We have a small problem. All four engines have stopped. We are doing our damnedest to get them going again. I trust you are not in too much distress.”

Pilot Eric Moody

On June 24, 1982, a British Airways Flight from London to Auckland found itself caught in a volcanic ash cloud whilst flying over Indonesia, causing the failure of all four of its engines. 41 year-old Pilot Eric Moody’s update to the plane’s passengers was instantly heralded as a ‘masterpiece’ of British understatement. The plane later landed safely.

3. “I am just going outside and may be some time.”

 

 

Captain Lawrence Oates

 

On March 16, 1912, the ill-fated British Antarctic Expedition, led by Robert Falcon Scott, was nearing its terminal stages.

 

Having reached the South Pole two months earlier, the men had found that they had been beaten by the Norwegian Roald Amundsen. The surviving four-man team then became encircled by a blizzard in a small tent with diminishing supplies, as temperatures plummeted to -400C. Oates’s gallant, if ultimately futile, gesture, as recorded in Scott’s diary, was aimed at raising his comrades’ chances of survival. It is regularly cited as one of the noblest examples of self-sacrifice in British history. Oates’ body was never found.

4. “This structure has novel features which are of considerable biological interest…”

James Watson & Francis Crick

Taken from Watson & Crick’s classic paper on the double helical structure of DNA, published in Nature, No, 171, April 25, 1953.

 

The influence of Watson & Crick’s theory has since proven incalculable, spawning numerous scientific advances and breakthroughs related to human cell regeneration, genetic matter, and hereditary diseases.

5. “A bit sticky, things are pretty sticky down there.”

Brigadier Thomas Brodie

 

On April 22 1951, 650 soldiers of the 1stBattalion, the Gloucestershire Regiment, were confronted by as many as 10,000 Chinese soldiers, during the struggle to secure access across the Imjin River during the Korean War.

 

In the midst of the ensuing battle, with ammunition running perilously low, Brigadier Thomas Brodie took a radio call from an American Major-General, enquiring about the regiment’s condition.

 

Taking Brodie’s colossal British-style understatement literally, the American chose to defer sending relief until the following morning. Only forty of the Glosters survived to tell the tale.

6. “One sometimes finds what one is not looking for.”

 

Sir Alexander Fleming

Fleming’s modest account of how, in 1928, he came to make one of the most important medical discoveries of the twentieth century: the discovery of penicillin.

7. “Much light will be thrown on man and his history.”

 

 

Sir Charles Darwin

Charles Darwin’s equally modest introduction to On the Origin of Species (1859), where he hints at the possible implications of his theory of natural selection.

 

Darwin’s theory is widely acknowledged as the foundation stone of all subsequent evolutionary biology.

8. “There seems to be something wrong with our bloody ships today.”

 

Admiral Lord David Beatty

In response to two of his flotilla of ships exploding in alarmingly quick succession of each other. Quoted whilst in command of the 1st Battlecruiser Squadron at the Battle of Jutland in May, 1916.

9. “We are in a very tight corner.”

Robert Falcon Scott

Scott’s final letter to his wife dated March 12, 1912. Found in the tent where his body and those of his companions were found the following year. (See No. 4 for a fuller sense of the ‘tight corner’ in which Scott and his fellow explorers found themselves.)

10. “It’s a drag, isn’t it?”

 

Sir Paul McCartney

 

McCartney’s reported first response to the news that his former song-writing partner, John Lennon, had been murdered in New York on December 8, 1980.

11. “I told you I was ill.”

 

Spike Milligan

The words inscribed (in Gaelic) on the former Goon’s headstone at St Thomas’s Church in Winchelsea, East Sussex.

 

In 2012, Milligan’s laconic summation of his life was voted the ‘nation’s favourite epitaph’ in a poll carried out for Marie Curie Cancer Care.

12. “I just made a balls of it, old boy. That’s all there was to it.”

Sir Douglas Bader, RAF Pilot

Commenting on the ill-executed aerobatic manoeuvre he attempted shortly after take-off in December 1931, which resulted in a crash and the loss of both of his legs. Bader’s logbook records the incident thus: ‘Crashed slow-rolling near ground. Bad show.’

13. “It is not all pleasure, this exploration.”

 

 

Dr David Livingstone

 

The enigmatic Scottish missionary and explorer’s synopsis, in April 1873, of the final months of his twenty-year quest through central Africa to find the source of the Nile. By this stage, Livingstone was suffering from both malaria and internal bleeding due to dysentery. He died the following month.

14. “There must have been about two minutes during which I assumed that I was killed. And that too was interesting.”

George Orwell

Recounting his experience of being shot in the throat whilst fighting against fascism in Spain, in 1937.

15. “Well, I’m still alive anyway.”

Queen Elizabeth II

The Queen’s response to being asked how she was by the Sinn Fein deputy first minister Martin McGuinness, during her visit to Northern Ireland on June 28, 2016. The trip was the Queen’s first public engagement since the UK had voted to leave the European Union five days earlier.

16. “We have before us an ordeal of the most grievous kind.”

 

 

 

Sir Winston Churchill

From Churchill’s first speech as Prime Minister to the House of Commons, delivered on May 13, 1940, in which he anticipated the all-encompassing nature of the struggle against Hitler and Nazism.

17. “Keep Calm and Carry On”

 

 

Ministry of Information

Produced during the build-up to the Second World War, in 1939, as a modest appeal to the British people to maintain their resolve in the face of impending crisis.

 

Since being ‘rediscovered’ in 2000, the phrase (as well as numerous variations on the theme) has come to be regarded as a key distillation of British national character.

18. “How different, how very different from the home life of our own dear Queen.”

Anon.

The alleged response of a Victorian audience member to Sarah Bernhardt’s depiction of Cleopatra in Covent Garden in 1892. In the final scene of the play by the French dramatist, Victorien Sardou, Cleopatra, kills a slave, after he reports the defeat of her lover Mark Antony, and then commits suicide.

19. “I’m afraid there is no money.”

 

Liam Byrne

The notoriously unadorned message left by Labour’s outgoing chief secretary to the Treasury to his coalition successor, David Laws, in May 2015. At the time, British national debt was estimated at over £1.5 trillion. Byrne has since expressed his enduring regret over the note.

20. “This place has gone off terribly.”

 

Dame Edith Evans (attributed)

Kenneth Williams’ account, as told to Michael Parkinson, of the redoubtable Dame Edith Evans’ response to an aged hotel waiter’s breaking wind, as he bent down to retrieve a bottle of wine.

ENDS
 

For more information, please contact: Fran Langdon or Laura Nugent at Van Communications:

[email protected] / [email protected] / 020 3179 0720
 

Notes to editors:

Dr Tom Dowling is an Honorary Research Fellow and Associate Tutor in the Department of History at the University of Sheffield. He completed his PhD on the history of ‘New Leftism in Britain’ in 2016. He is a co- founder and senior editor of the Labour Pains Project, an ongoing collaboration between historians at the University of Sheffield and the People’s History Museum in Manchester, exploring both historic and contemporary divisions in the British labour movement. He is currently writing a book on left-wing sensibilities in Britain since the 1930s.
 

Privilege

Privilege Insurance specialises in car insurance for safe drivers. It also offers home insurance and breakdown cover by phone or on-line.

Privilege general insurance policies are underwritten by U K Insurance Limited, Registered office: The Wharf, Neville Street, Leeds LS1 4AZ. Registered in England and Wales No 1179980. U K Insurance Limited is authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority.

Privilege and U K Insurance Limited are both part of Direct Line Insurance Group plc.  

Customers can find out more about Privilege’s products or get a quote by calling 0345 246 0515 or visiting www.privilege.co.uk